Amazon.com Widgets

Tuesday, January 3, 2006

The folks at CSICOP, the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal, has a podcast, Point of Inquiry, which is pretty good.

I used to be a big fan of CSICOP and the whole "skeptic" thing, and I still am, even though I've soured a bit. I think they're great when exposing and explaining ghosts, ghoulies and UFO's. It's when they take turn toward an apparent hostility to regular mainstream religion and spirituality that I begin to be left cold. It all starts to sound very childish to me -- like high schoolers rebelling against their parents for making them go to Sunday School all those years. They end up going too far and throwing the baby out with the bath water.

So I enjoyed the December 16 podcast (for those unfamiliar with podcasting -- it's basically a radio show in mp3 format. You download the file and listen to it on your I-Pod or similar, or, for those without, you just listen on your computer) with guest Joe Nickell where he advises skeptics to spend more time in "skeptical inquiry," and less time "debunking" -- the difference being mainly one of attitude. Unfortunately, much of the beginning of the show is taken up with discussion of a new book, The Trouble With Christmas...exactly the type of thing I wish the skeptics wouldn't waste their time on.

The POI people might also at some point decide whether "Inquiry" is pronounced in-QUIRE-ry or IN-quiry. I go with the latter.

2 Comments

Interesting post and thanks for the media recommendation. I have now listened to all episodes, including Max Maven's. I agree with what you said about their skepticism of religion which can come off sounding spoil-sport and hostile, but I do think Ibn Warraq makes some good points about extremist Islam as well as the discussion in another episode about secularism.

Thanks for your comment. I hadn't check back since putting up this post and didn't know about the Warraq or Maven entries. I will give them both a listen.

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Search


Archives
[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]