Amazon.com Widgets

Tuesday, February 8, 2005

The following was left as a comment to the post below.

As the editor of the student newspaper in platteville, I encourage people to write in to the paper with opinions on divestment. Plattevile is very homogenous and I appreciate insightful comments from outside the community. letters must have a phone number to confirm identity in order to be published.

Much of the mail I have recieved critical of divestment has been well written and actually brought up points we made in our editorial on the subject.

1) A divestment of israel ingores the human rights abuses of other regimes in the mideast and around the world

2) Racists have used seemingly valid criticism of Israel to promote hatred

3) Isreal has been a major force for peace in the last half century

4) taking Isreal's actions out of context from the whole picture of Mideast violence paints a distorted picture of the middle east

Still, the divestment issue brings up legitimate questions and I think my readers would be very interested in a pro israeli response.

Do pro-isaeli people deny the allegations made by those supporting divestment?

Most of the charges of human rights abuses made against Isreal by pro-divestment have been backed by Amnesty International.

Conservative Jews have veiwed all Iraelli divestment racist.
Questions...

In what context is criticism of Isreali national security policy NOT racism?

Would ANY (Israeli)government action justify sanctions?

If so, how is this context different?

Having contact with people on faculty senate, I highly doubt anti semitism had anything to do with the vote.

Thanks and I look forward to hearing from you

(exponent@uwplatt.edu)


[an error occurred while processing this directive]

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Search


Archives
[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]