Amazon.com Widgets

Saturday, May 8, 2010

YNet has a hard-hitting investigation into Goldstone's South African past: Judge Goldstone's dark past

Yedioth Ahronoth investigation reveals man preaching human rights, who authored scathing report against Israel's operation in Gaza, sent at least 28 black defendants to gallows as South African judge under Apartheid regime

He asserted that Israel committed war crimes and came out against the Israel Defense Forces, whom he claimed violated basic human rights. Judge Richard Goldstone forgot just one thing - to look long and hard in the mirror and to do some soul-searching before he rushes to criticize others.

A special Yedioth Ahronoth investigation reveals Richard Goldstone's dark side as a judge during the Apartheid era in South Africa. It turns out, the man who authored the Goldstone Report criticizing the IDF's actions during Operation Cast Lead took an active part in the racist policies of one of the cruelest regimes of the 20th century.

During his tenure as sitting as judge in the appellant court during the 1980s and 1990s sentenced dozens of blacks mercilessly to their death...

The article is a bit more hung up on the matter of the death penalty itself than the Apartheid context it took place in, but be that as it may...

Goldstone has a response, here: Judge Goldstone responds to death penalty story. It's ultimately fairly weak. Goldstone need not have been a judge, after all, he could have remained a privately practicing attorney. The picture of Goldstone that begins to emerge in all this is that of a stop at nothing careerist doing his best to ingratiate himself with whoever is in power in order to climb the ladder. At the time it was Apartheid, now it's bashing Israelis.

Dershowitz has an absolutely must-read here: Legitimating Bigotry: The Legacy of Richard Goldstone

Richard Goldstone, author of the notorious Goldstone report, did not become a South African judge in the post-Apartheid Mandela Era, as The New York Times and other media have erroneously reported. He accepted a judgeship during the worst days of Apartheid and helped legitimate one of the most racist regimes in the world by granting the imprimatur of the rule of law to some of the most undemocratic and discriminatory decrees.

Goldstone was--quite literally--a hanging judge. He imposed and affirmed death sentences for more than two dozen blacks under circumstances where whites would almost certainly have escaped the noose. And he affirmed sentences of physical torture--euphemistically called "flogging"-- for other blacks. He also enforced miscegenation and other racist laws with nary a word of criticism or dissent. He was an important part of the machinery of death, torture and racial subjugation that characterized Apartheid South Africa. His robe and gavel lent an air of legitimacy to an entirely illegitimate and barbaric regime...[Read it all!]

Jim Wald comments here and points out:

...In one sense, Goldstone's record does not bear on the significance of his Report, which will stand or fall on its merits. But given that the document prompted widespread charges of bias, the investigation may yet prove to be pertinent to a new reading. Already we are hearing suggestions that Goldstone's opinions there (but presumably in other recent endeavors, as well), far from representing a set of neutral analyses, in fact reflected a sort of perverse overcompensation for a blemished moral past about which he preferred to keep silent. In the words of Deputy Foreign Minister Ayalon, "This so-called respected judge is using this [Gaza] report in order to atone for his sins and gain international legitimacy."

1 Comment

Sol,

With regard to Goldstone's past here's a pdf doc and on page 9 Goldstone damaged South Africa as well, a review of a book authored by Dr. Anthea Jeffery, head of special research at the South African Institute of Race Relations, "People's War: New Light on the Struggle for South Africa in which she discusses his making fast and free with the evidence regarding the upsurge in political killings prior to independence, in which some 15000 people were killed.
It was basically a whitewash of the ANC's military wing and the blame was laid at the door of the Inkatha party's door.

27-november-2009.pdf

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Search


Archives
[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]