Thursday, May 14, 2009

Charles Radin, former Bureau Chief for the Boston Globe in Jerusalem, recently arranged a debate between Joshua Rubenstein, Amnesty International's man in New England and Gerald Steinberg, Director of NGO Monitor, a Jerusalem based watchdog organization that specifically critiques "Human Rights" groups that, according to their analysis, maintain a double standard and disproportional apparatus of criticism when it comes to Israel.

It is no secret that Mr. Rubenstein's AI, a powerful international force with over 2 million members and a budget of nearly 200 million dollars, has been highly critical of Israel, regardless of whether a left or right government is in power. According to Steinberg, groups like Amnesty and Human Rights Watch, in their obsession with Israel, have "undermined the very human rights values that they claim to promote by demonizing Israel." Founded in 2001 by Steinberg in reaction to the hate fest against Israel and Jews that took place in Durban, South Africa, NGO Monitor was instrumental in exploding the 2003 Jenin "massacre" myth, propagated in large part by Amnesty. Predictably, he continued, Amnesty evinced virtually no concern over the fate of IDF soldier,Gilad Shalit, held incommunicado by Hamas for over three years and denied visits by the International Committee of the Red Cross. More recently, AI's treatment of the Gaza War, according to Steinberg, has gone from "illegitimate criticism to absurdity" in its disproportionate and inaccurate attacks on Israel.

Steinberg then went on to list 7 basic violations of the very tenets of human rights norms ranging from predefining victims (Palestinians) and perpetrators (Israelis) regardless of the facts on the ground to the failure of "independent investigation" (Amnesty relied on Hamas casualty figures, which claimed a virtual totality of "civilian" deaths).

In what seemed at times, a less than spirited defense of his employer, Rubenstein, fell back on AI's garnering of a Nobel Prize in 1977, its important work indicting the Mugabe regime in Zimbabwe and the oft-repeated claim that "Amnesty is tough on everybody."

During the Q & A, Louise Cohen asked him that, given his statement that Israel has a right to defend itself, what specifically are legitimate forms of self-defense that would be acceptable to him or Amnesty? She pointed out that contemporary war will never be as simple as a Gettysburg battle diorama, with each side lined up and color-coded, while the civilians look on from a hilltop.  If self-defense is not to become an extinct animal in today's world, which actions would Amnesty approve?

What he or AI would do in the face of such asymmetrical warfare when fanatics use human shields to attack Israeli civilians, left Rubenstein pondering, "Frankly, I don't have an answer to that." Of course, that begs the question: "If you have no answer to that central question, then why is AI so quick to disproportionately condemn one party?"

A lot of questions went unanswered that day, including one from an Israeli IDF veteran who served in Jenin during the make-believe "massacre" and who had experienced the "human shield" phenomenon in action.

In light of the overwhelming evidence of bias and the agenda-driven record of Amnesty International presented by Steinberg, Rubenstein's defense would have been better served had he acknowledged even a modicum of legitimate criticism. Instead, the audience was left with generalities, resting on Nobel Prize laurels and the faith of a true believer: "My Amnesty -- Right or Wrong."

Here is video of Gerald Steinberg's excellent opening remarks. My apologies for the less than stellar quality of the video and audio. I was using a cell camera:

[Solomon: From what I've seen of the video, Hillel understates the case. Rubenstein exposes AI as an organization completely adrift, without real responses, and thus bleeding relevancy. What he lacks for answers he tries to make up with demeanor (swagger) and it doesn't work with an audience that sees through him -- something I bet he rarely, if ever, faces. I'll be posting up some more audio and video later. I only wish I had been there to get more video. Readers will enjoy this.]

Update: More video. We come in as Steinberg and Rubenstein question each other, then take audience comments:

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Slugfest -- Amnesia International KO'ed in Round One (Updated).

TrackBack URL for this entry:

A little argument isn't dimming NGO Monitor's passion: Amnesty in 2008: Anti-Israel Obsession Continues to Undermine Moral Principles In 2008, Amnesty again focused disproportionately on Israel's response to aggression from Gaza, and led the NGO campai... Read More

1 Comment

Tough to watch in the beginning, but well worth the effort.

Really good stuff.

"Syme: It's a beautiful thing, the destruction of words. You wouldn't have seen the [Newspeak] Dictionary 10th edition, would you Smith? It's that thick. [illustrates thickness with fingers] The 11th Edition will be that [narrows fingers] thick. Winston Smith: So, The Revolution will be complete when the language is perfect? Syme: The secret is to move from translation, to direct thought, to automatic response. No need for self-discipline. Language coming from here [the larynx], not from here [the brain]" -1984 (film)


Blogroll Me!

Adam Holland
Agam's Gecko
Amy Ridenour
Armies of Liberation
Astute Blogger
Backseat Blogger
Barry Rubin
Blazing Cat Fur
Boker tov, Boulder
Bosch Fawstin
Breath of the Beast
Challah Hu Akbar
CiF Watch
Cinnamon Stillwell
Classical Values
Combs Spouts Off
Conservative Grapevine
Conservative Oasis Contentions
Contentious Centrist
Cox & Forkum
Creeping Sharia
Dancing with Dogs
Dave Bender
Davids Medienkritik
Dean Esmay
Defending Crusader
Democracy Project
Dreams Into Lightning
Dutchblog Israel
Exit Zero
Ghost of a Flea
GM's Place
The God Blog
Huff-Po Monitor
In Context
Insignificant Thoughts
Iraq the Model
Israel Matzav
Israel Seen
J Street Jive
Jerusalem Diaries
Jerusalem Posts
Jewish State
Kesher Talk
Legal Insurrection
Liberty's Spirit
Marathon Pundit
The Marmot's Hole
Martin Kramer
Matthew K. Tabor
Mere Rhetoric
Michelle Malkin
Mick Hartley
Mind of Mog
My Machberet
My Wide Blue Seas
Never Yet Melted
One Jerusalem
Paula Says
Point of no Return
Political inSecurity
Random Thoughts
Ranting Sandmonkey
Red Planet Cartoons
Right Wing News
Roger L. Simon
Seraphic Secret
Shawarma Mayor
Shining City
Simply Jews
Soccer Dad
A Soldier's Mother
Solomon's House
Something Something
Somewhere on A1A
Stand for Israel
Survival Tips: The Survivalist Blog
Tasty Infidelicacies
Tel Chai Nation
Texican Tattler
Themistocles' Shade
This Ain't Hell
Tikkun Olam
Tom Glennon
Tools of Renewal
Tundra Tabloids
UCC Truths
Vicious Babushka
The View From Here
View From Iran
The World
Yaacov Lozowick
Yid With Lid

:New England Blogs:
Augean Stables
Bloodthirsty Liberal
Boston Maggie
Boston's Patriots
Boulevard Girl
Business of Life
Daniel in Brookline
Hub Blog
Hub Politics
Jules Crittenden
Libertarian Leanings
Maggie's Farm
Miss Kelly
N.E. Republican
People's Republicans
Pundit Review
Red Mass Group
Sippican Cottage
Squaring the Globe
Universal Hub
Weekend Pundit
Who Knew?

Blogroll Policy

If You Enjoy This Site
Paypal Donate

Amazon Purchase
(Buy yourself something with this link and I will get a percentage.)

My Amazon Wish List

Worth a Click





Solomonia Button

Smaller Button

Smallest Button

Note on Permissions:
You may feel free to use anything you find on this site as long as you're not selling it. Just give credit where credit is due is all. Thanks for stopping by!

Site (C)2003-2009

This site will not display properly at screen resolutions of less than 1024px wide.

Solomonia Store




Martin Solomon

Mary Madigan

Hillel Stavis


Jon Haber
Jon Haber


Opinions expressed are those of the individual. No one speaks for any organization unless expressly stated.

Enter your Email for a Daily Digest of New Posts

Preview | Powered by FeedBlitz
(Be sure to whitelist if you aren't receiving updates.)

Click here for other subscription options, including Twitter, AIM, MSM and others.

Follow me on Twitter



 Subscribe in a reader


EN 160x600 B

Quality Diamond Crosses