Amazon.com Widgets

Monday, December 8, 2008

Terrific response to a despicable piece posted at Engage: (a snip)

...It was Caroline Lucas who, unlike the Bihari migrant workers, happened on this occasion to be in the right place at the right time. Caroline Lucas, should the name mean nothing to you, is the elfin leader of the Green Party. But she could, as far as attributing the usual culpability is concerned, have been anyone at that end of British politics. Reader, I could have gone on the programme and said what she said for her. To wit, Iraq and Afghanistan prove we can't bring peace at the end of a gun (though it would seem that "understanding" can be found at the end of a terrorist's gun), many people see the "war on terror" as a war on Muslims (a point that fails to distinguish between what people choose to "see" and what is the truth of the matter), and, in her actual words, "if we are to defeat extremism we have to go to the root causes of it - we have to look in particular at countries like Palestine".

We are not unsubtle in this column. We understand that a simmering resentment will not always express itself rationally or fairly. In frustration, the angry often kill the wrong people in the wrong places. But to argue that Palestine fuelled the massacre at Mumbai, that the Hindu waiter shot in the forehead after serving water to a terrorist was paying for the inequities of Gaza, that he wasn't already, in the eyes of that terrorist, expendable enough as an unbeliever, as one who had stolen Kashmir, or simply as a spot of target practice en route to a mad and misguided martyrdom, is not only preposterous, it is irresponsible...

The rest, and don't miss the video of Jacobson from an earlier appearance at the bottom of the post if you haven't already seen it. [h/t: Adam Holland]

2 Comments

unless all Jews are held to be complicit in the strangulation of Gaza,

What is the problem, if even after 2000 years all Jews, and not just Israeli ones, are held to be complicit in the death of Jesus?
At least Ms. Lucas is being consistent even if in other material she hypocritically espouses the PC way.

Yes, the video of Howard Jacobson speaking is great. Well worth 9 minutes of your time.

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Search


Archives
[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]