Friday, October 19, 2007
Blair: Terror threat like fascism
NEW YORK -- Former British Prime Minister Tony Blair has said the world must not be "forced into retreat" against Islamic terrorists as it faced a situation similar to the Nazi threat before World War II.
In his first major speech since leaving office in June, Blair told a charity dinner in New York: "Analogies with the past are never properly accurate and analogies especially with the rising fascism can be easily misleading but in pure chronology I sometimes wonder if we're not in the 1920s or 1930s again.
"This ideology now has a state, Iran, that is prepared to back and finance terror in the pursuit of destabilizing countries whose people wish to live in peace."
Blair's speech Thursday came days after U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates reiterated the Bush administration's stance that "all options" must be kept "on the table" in confronting the threats posed by Iran. This was a reference to the option of using military action against the long-time U.S. adversary.
Addressing the issue of terrorists, Blair continued: "There is a tendency even now, even in some of our own circles, to believe that they are as they are because we have provoked them and if we left them alone they would leave us alone," he said.
Blair, who gave strong personal backing to U.S. President George W. Bush after the September 11, 2001 attacks, added: "I fear this is mistaken. They have no intention of leaving us alone...
Blair frames it all nicely, very even-handed, well balanced. No analogy is perfectly fitting, a perferct parallel, or at least very few are. This present situation is certainly sui generis in some respects, the the fascist analogy broadly works, the early bolshevik analogy works well also, in terms of a focus on some forms of praxis, other factors as well.
In the end they're only analogies and the unique qualities of the current situation always need to be kept in mind. But understood reasonably, proportionately, those analogies work.